South Korea Halts Release of Jeju Air Crash Report Amid Protests from Victims' Families
South Korean authorities have withdrawn a report on the Jeju Air crash following protests from families, who allege it prematurely blames the pilots.
/https://aviacionlinecdn.eleco.com.ar/media/2024/12/jeju_air_737_800.jpg)
Aviation authorities in South Korea abruptly canceled the presentation of an intermediate report on the crash of a Jeju Air Boeing 737-800, which occurred last December 29. The decision was made following a tense confrontation with the victims' families, who disrupted a scheduled press conference at Muan International Airport.
The conflict arose after a private briefing where investigators from the Aviation and Railway Accident Investigation Board (ARAIB) presented their preliminary findings to the bereaved. According to the families, the report seemed to prematurely attribute responsibility for the accident, which claimed the lives of 179 of the 181 people on board, to the flight crew and a bird strike.
Pillkyu Hwang, a lawyer representing the families, took the podium intended for the investigators to express the group's discontent, stating that "the families did not get an adequate explanation." In his remarks, the lawyer pointed out that the report, in its current wording, "in fact, depending on how you look at it, it kind of puts all the blame on the dead birds and the dead pilots."
The lawyer, as reported by The New York Times, criticized the lack of caution in the presented conclusions. Hwang added that while that might be the outcome of the investigation, "that requires tremendous rigor and very careful wording. And something came out that wasn’t careful at all."
Frequently Asked Questions about the Crash
What happened to the Jeju Air flight? A Boeing 737-800 crashed on December 29, 2024, during its approach to Muan Airport, South Korea, resulting in 179 fatalities.
Why are the families protesting? They believe the ARAIB's preliminary report is inadequate and hasty in pointing to the pilots and a bird strike as the main causes before a thorough investigation is complete.
Are bird strikes dangerous? Yes. A bird strike, especially with a flock, can cause severe engine damage, such as a loss of thrust. Managing such an emergency is a critical procedure for flight crews.
The investigation team planned to publicly disclose that the analysis of the aircraft's CFM56-7B engines found no inherent technical faults, which shifts the focus of the investigation toward operational and external factors. However, the families fear that the release of a report with this focus would be interpreted by the media and the public as a final conclusion, stigmatizing the deceased pilots before all variables were thoroughly analyzed.
In a statement, the families' delegation argued that the report's framing could imply a premature closure of the case. An aircraft accident investigation is a complex process consisting of several stages, including data collection, analysis of the black boxes (FDR and CVR), and the evaluation of all contributing factors.
For now, the ARAIB has not announced a new date for the publication of its findings. The investigation continues as the aviation community and those affected await a complete and rigorous analysis to clarify the exact circumstances that led to the tragedy.
Para comentar, debés estar registradoPor favor, iniciá sesión